Manchester United faced harsh post-match criticism from former captain Roy Keane after their 3-0 defeat to Manchester City, targeting Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire. While Keane described Shaw as having “given up” and suggested Maguire had “got away with murder,” the response from the duo drew praise from another legendary Red, Rio Ferdinand.
Maguire Shows Leadership
Maguire made his 250th appearance for United in the City game and subsequently leapt to the defence of colleague Shaw after the Chelsea win. The former United defender emphasized that senior players needed to protect their teammates. “Personally I think it is great from Harry Maguire because that is the job of a captain/senior player to come in and defend your players if you think that they are being unfairly treated,” Ferdinand told MEN Sport. Maguire’s reply was one of leadership and loyalty, showing he can protect his team from unfair criticism by continuing to focus on collective performance.
Shaw’s Courage and Talent
Luke Shaw also came across extremely well, he took Keane’s criticism on the chin and showed a level of maturity and understanding. Ferdinand commented, “I like to see players come out and go: ‘You know what, I am not having that or actually, they are right. I was under par for the level that I have set myself.’” He commended Shaw’s powers of recovery despite experiencing injury setbacks and insisted retaining match fitness is crucial to delivering top-level displays at such an elite club.
Author’s Opinion
Ferdinand’s defense highlights the balance between constructive criticism and personal attacks. Both Shaw and Maguire responded with professionalism, showing leadership, resilience, and integrity. In modern football, mental strength is as crucial as skill, and these reactions underline why United’s defenders remain vital. Keane’s comments may spark debate, but the duo’s composed handling proves they are up to the challenge of performing under pressure and scrutiny.
As featured on ManUNews.com
